10
Aug 2010
Filed in » eye product reviews, makeup, product swatches
I know most of you probably already own this product, or have at least seen/heard about it. It’s everywhere! In ads all over the place, pretty much everyone and their mama has one in the beauty community on Youtube, they’re all over Ebay. You cannot escape them. I’m talking about the infamous 120-color eyeshadow palette. The coloring book size double-stack eyeshadow palette with 120 juicy colors.
This palette is sold by many different companies and depending on the retailer, you may see different logos and lettering on the front of each palette. However, no matter who you buy it from — it’s the exact same palette. They’re all made in the same country, just shipped out to different retailers so they can slap their own logos on’em and sell them to you. Seriously. I think there several editions of this palette as well, with each edition having different colors.
You can find this just about anywhere online from $20 – $30 a piece on average. If you pay over $30, you’re being ripped off. Also, be aware that any palette you see like this that has the MAC Cosmetics logo on it, is a fake. MAC doesn’t make this product, so don’t get the rug pulled from underneath you.
Ingredients:Talcum Powder, Kaolin, Mica Powder, Magnesium Stearate, Titanium White Powder, Colorant, Pearl Lustre Mica Powder, Magnesium Stearate, Silicon Oil, Titanium White Powder.








Each shadow is about the same size as a dime, and come in a slightly mounted dome shape


I did some swatches of just a few of the colors, and it took a little bit of effort to pack them on just to get them to show up properly. As you can see on my fingers, the consistency is very powdery and loose. These shadows aren’t pressed very well. The matte formulas are pressed a little better than the shimmery ones, but they’re still too soft and fluffy for my liking.



Chunky, right?
PROS
- Great value.
- Easy to find in most countries.
- Great for the beginners.
- 120 beautiful colors in the pan.
CONS
- Heavy factory smell. It’s pretty funky to me, I don’t like it. It smells cheap.
- Powdery/soft/fluffy eyeshadow texture.
- Half of the colors aren’t very pigmented, and disappear with application.
- Because of the soft and fragile texture, lots of people have complained that they’ve received this palette with the shadows completely shattered. That’s no good.
- Quality isn’t all that great compared to other brands.
OVERALL
I remember seeing this about two years ago and wanting one for myself to see what the fuss was, and I got it a little over a year ago — and I barely touch it. I haven’t used every single color in this palette, but the ones I have tried just haven’t given me what I need to go back to this palette repeatedly. I don’t hate it, but I don’t love it either. I haven’t completely given up on it, but as of now, I don’t think its that great in comparison to Make Up For Ever, NARS or even MAC eyeshadows.
I honestly think this is a great palette for beginners who are interested in playing with different colors, and trying different looks. You have 120 colors to experiment with, so for some of you this may be worth the investment. It’s a good way to introduce yourself to the huge world of cosmetics.
All of the colors are really pretty, but you don’t always get great color payoff with them which is sad. Some of the colors break down on your lid to some sort of colored powdered substance and they just… disappear
You’re like, “Wait a second, I know I just put eyeshadow on…so where the hell is it??”
At the end of the day, it might be worth trying. It’s definitely not gonna put a hole in your pocket by any means. Many of you may find this is a classic case of “You get what you pay for”. It might work better for you if you use good brushes and a good eyeshadow base, its up to you. If you hate it, give it to your little sister — or brother
RATING

Availability: Amazon







My friend recently bought a “M.A.C.” 120 Palette. I told her M.A.C. doesn’t make a 120 palette and if they did it wouldn’t cost $20. She called me a Makeup snob. So I walked out the room laughing….poor thang!
LMAO!!!
I have one of these and….:crickets:
It’s good to own if you are 12….or good to look at…or something like that. lol
LOL!! I kinda agree. Great for beginners, but even when you get better with makeup and start learning more, you probably wont want anything to do with this palette. Mine just sits on my desk collecting dust. I liked it when I first got it, but the more I started using it, i was like “ehhhhh…this isn’t all that”. It smells bad too!
Glad I read this review, because I wanted to try it, now I won’t.
I think if people want their money’s worth they should try coastal scents. I’ve never had a problem with them, and they’re affordable.
I have the Coastal Scents 88 palette. But from what I understand the same company that makes the 120 makes the 88 and ships it all over so her review would prolly be the same for that too.
That said it’s been great for helping me try out color and figure this makeup ish out since i’m kind of a newbie. Like Resha said it’s a great beginner palette. For instance, I learned I cant wear 75% of them 88 colors without lookin a plum clown fool which is why I’ve gotten into complimentary MAC pigments, etc., and will be investing in a UD Naked Palette as soon as I can get my hands on one
It would have cost me a grip to trial and error my way through all that color in Sephora or even a drugstore to figure that out. Plus I still do use it for experimentation cus it’ll work with a good base. So i’d call this a fair review since its value isn’t quite in its quality but in its usefulness in the makeup discovery process.
Love the blog!
Thanks Shai. I tried to be as fair as I could
Glad you can appreciate the review!
Thank you for the reply. I didn’t know CS used the same palette. I agree with you on it thought. While I do love the palette, There’s some colors I just can’t wear. But it has been great to see what colors are good for me so I can buy some singles.
Yea Coastal Scents uses the same palettes too. Same product.
Thanks for that, I had no clue CS uses the same palette.
you’re exactly right about the “beginner” statement. i feel the same way about elf shadows too. it gives us room to learn how to apply and blend and combine colors. you can’t START practicing with MUFE and NARS, you’ll just waste them. the 120 palette has cheap product so you can wipe it off everytime you fuck up lol.
does anyone else notice how the pinks will just disintegrate off you lid??? try to do a look with their pink, that whole row is garb!
Yup, exactly. These shadows, while not great, are awesome for beginners. Gives them a playing field to screw around in. But for the intermediate/advanced, they’d probably laugh at this lol. I should sell mine because I never use it smh. The Pink colors are the worst! so are the oranges
love all these colors! come follow me xoxo
Btw
I went home to swatch mine and my consistancy was a little less powdery than yours looks.
but…I swatched the Cameo (the brand of mines) on one hand and my mac shadows on one hand and after 15 mins, the Cameo shadows went ghost & my lovely mac shadows were still there in all of its lovely pigmented glory.
LOL i believe it!
Chile please. I bought this thing for my little sisters to use. They’re 13 and 15…they love it.
ME though? Uh uh no way….
LOL!
120, 88 palettes are only good for when you’re trying to do a look and you need a specific color you don’t have in your regular eyeshadow stash. I would NEVER do a look using ONLY the palette colors. The only time I have ever gotten them to “work” is when mixed in with my MAC. I don’t get how they get such rave reviews. I mean, I guess for $20 it’s well worth the price… but still, definitely not something to call home about.
wow, This is the first review I have read where someone who had this palette hated it. the you tube makeup gurus make this palette look so good, that I have been craving it for months. I am shocked that you have had it for so long and it still looks new. Only reason I haven’t brought it was because people want to charge me a total of 28 just to ship it and that’s not happening, but it funny to see that people are paying 200 for it on ebay because its a mac. Nice review, oh and if you dont want your can I have it? lol(kinda serious though)
Real talk is real. ^_^
I’ve got an 88 palette that is just as dusty. The colour payoff is fine, until you start blending.. then the pigmentation heads to greener pastures, or something.
I can’t lie, I’ve seen some fantastic looks done with these palettes – but I haven’t had much luck using them. I hear stickier bases can help.
Yours is the MOST honest review I’ve seen for this product. Although I’m a beginner, I don’t wanna waste my cash on a product that’s doesn’t perform well. I’ll continue to “play” w/the NYX singles. Thanks much, Resha!
To be completely honest with you, I have a couple MAC eyeshadows, and I also own this palette, and I have to disagree with you. I don’t know if I’m getting bad batches of MAC eyeshadows, but I’ve never once been satisfied. They’ve never been very pigmented for me and when I go to pack on the eyeshadow, it doesn’t build up very well. In fact, I don’t think I’ve been very satisfied with many of the MAC products I’ve purchased (besides my lip conditioner, studio finish concealer, & vanilla pigment).
I actually really like this palette, and I’m definitely not a beginner into makeup. The matte colors aren’t very pigmented for me though, however the shimmery ones are very pigmented. I actually like the softness of the eyeshadows, however it definitely fluctuates between a pro and a con for me since the eyeshadows shatter so easily. But pigmentation & lasting wise, these eyeshadows seem to work better than my MAC ones. However, if anyone has a recommendation of a MAC eyeshadow that might make me think otherwise, I’m always willing to hear.
But yeah, nice to hear another one’s honest opinion! I definitely agree with you on some points.
After having this palette for a year and trying it out a few times and then again last night I can finally say I completely agree with you. I’m not satisfy with the color payoff or blending (it is very hard to blend even with two faced eye shadow primer). Although I’m pretty new at eye makeup and i really need to practice more on my technique and everything. I’ll probably get some high-end makeup or continue to get my drugstore faves like NYX for green eyes or something else. if you have any recommendations please share, lol thanks
which edition do you have? like what kind is the whole thing lol ur colors look alot better than mine!