16
May 2010
Filed in » mac, product swatches, tips & tricks
Are your eyelids as oily as Jermaine Jackson? If you find your eyeshadow just doesn’t stay on your oily lids, you might wanna try a paint pot by MAC ($16.50). Not only do they apply smoothly and dry quickly, but they can make your eyeshadows so much more vibrant. I prefer them over other types of eye primers, but it’s up to you. I still love my UDPP and Too Faced Shadow Insurance, but I reach for my paint pots a lot more. Some of the shades are so pretty you could wear them alone (like Indianwood and Rubenesque), and some really enhance any duochrome shadow you might be wearing. Artifact paint pot looks amazing with Beauty Marked eyeshadow, and Pink Pearl pigment over Delft?? Gorgeous. There are so many things you can do with paint pots, it’s not even funny. I don’t have every single one, but I have a pretty good variety to start with (and will quietly hunt for the ones I don’t have and need). Check out these swatches so you know what they look like on darker skin.
These are great because they create a pigmented barrier between your oily lid situation and your eyeshadow, and keep the eyeshadow lasting longer than Bob Dole. What does that mean? Little to no creasing! If you have extremely oily lids, I’m not sure if these will work for you…maybe you can layer some UDPP and a paintpot? Not sure, but try whatever works for you.

I store mine in a tray I got from Ikea called Anordna Mest (now only comes in white)


Row 1: Painterly, Bare Study, Soft Ochre, Girl Friendly, Artifact, Delft, Rollickin’, Electro Sky
Row 2: Rubenesque, Indianwood, Coral Crepe, Quite Natural, Greenstroke, Otherworldly, Pharaoh, Moss Scape
Paint Pots come in four finishes: Pearl, Cream, Frost and Satin. I can’t remember what all of these finishes are, so I’ll try my best lol.

*No Flash from right to left: Painterly (cream), Bare Study (frost), Soft Ochre (cream), Girl Friendly (cream)

*No flash from right to left: Rubenesque (frost), Indianwood (frost), Coral Crepe (satin)

*No flash from right to left: Coral Crepe (satin), Quite Natural (cream), Artifact (frost)

*With flash from right to left: Painterly (cream), Bare Study (frost), Soft Ochre (cream), Girl Friendly (cream), Rubenesque (frost), Indianwood (frost)

*With flash from right to left: Soft Ochre (cream), Girl Friendly (cream), Rubenesque (frost), Indianwood (frost), Coral Crepe (satin), Quite Natural (cream), Artifact (frost)

*No flash from right to left: Electro Sky (cream), Delft (frost), Rollickin’ (frost), Otherworldly (cream)

*No flash from top to bottom: Moss Scape (frost), Greenstroke (frost), Otherworldly (cream)

*No flash from top to bottom: Pharaoh (cream), Moss Scape (frost), Greenstroke (frost)

*With flash from left to right: Electro Sky (cream), Delft (frost), Rollickin’ (frost), Otherworldly (cream), Greenstroke (frost), Moss Scape (frost), Pharaoh (cream)
Pretty, right? They’re also long lasting but kind of a beeyotch to remove. Coincidentally, you might need an oil-based makeup remover to get it off easily. You could use an oil-free makeup remover…it just might take you a while. While swatching these just now, I removed them with a regular oil-free makeup remover wipe and I had to scrub the crap outta my arm, now it’s raw. See what I go thru for you guys?
Some of the colors on my arm are no longer available because they were “limited edition” (MAC is good for doing that crap) or discontinued, but you might be able to find some at CCO’s. It’s worth a look *shrug*. The sad news is that they literally just discontinued Delft paint pot like within the last month or so. Why MAC, why???
APPLICATION AND REMOVAL
- Best applied with a clean finger over the lid or with a clean brush (such as a MAC 242 or 217).
- Best removed with an oil-based makeup remover or wipe.
Anyhoo, I hope this post was helpful for those of you looking to buy paint pots and curious about how they look on darker skin, how pigmented they are, etc. These can be applied as sheer or as opaque as you want. My swatches are pretty opaque just to show you how much color pay-off you can get.
Availability: MAC Cosmetics (including counters and stores)






Coral Crepe is mah jaayyyuum, lol!
“Are your eyelids as oily as Jermaine Jackson?”
you just can’t act right. ROFL!
LMAO!
Coral Crepe is my FAVORITE in the world!
Anyhoo…I use cold cream or vaseline to get mine off. Just a small amount left on the lid for about a minute and it comes off clean.
Yes, vaseline is a great makeup remover…esp when u warm it up a bit in ur hands/fingers. Great tip boo
LMAO @ Jermaine Jackson hahahaha. Thought I was the only one to notice the grease pot.
I like the paint pots, have Ground Work.
P.S. BEST review I have ever seen, so in-depth and informative. Thanks!
This was a great review, thanks!!
Thanks hun
“Bob Dole” hahahahah.
I never considered paint pots before but these swatches are tempting. I agree with you on Indianwood, and painterly looks pretty nice also
Painterly is one of my most used because it gives you a totally blank canvas to work with, and certain shadows really pop on top of painterly. i highly recommend that one.
I do love Coral Crepe, but girl you have to check out the MUFE aqua creams. They are at Sephora now and they are the BEST.
Aw man I saw those…and I cannot wrap my head around them just yet. I may pick some up next month though. I’m on a strict budget LOL!
#stopthepress …..The paintpots are PRIMERS? I’ve had ‘Artifact’ for about 4 months now and i’ve been using it as a main eyeshadow! The SA at MAC didn’t tell me it was a primer smh lol
Lovely Shades!
LMAO yes babe they can be used as primers!
First of all; L O V E the site just lovelovelovee
Yet,as a beginner in the getting-into-more-professional-ish-looking-make up I feel that I am about to be even MORE broke than I already am..Lesigh! Why do I have this intense feeling that I NEED them all in my life ASAP..Lord help me. Great post.
Much love all the way from Amsterdam,the Netherlands
Amsterdam! Thats awesome. thanks for the kind words
Whats your skin tone? I can help you narrow down your first three paintpots so you don’t go overboard lol
Im already counting the days till my paycheck lol. I follow u on twitter n u me as well .com/aidaa_ )so u could see a bit on that picture but my skintone is i guess a bit beyonce ish but the undertone is sooo yellow with redspots which makes it hard to find a good foundation. I use mac select spf15 nc40 and when i want a bit more color i mix it with bobbi brown oil free even finish in honey 5. Im gonna search for the revlon color stay though
Fab post – thank you!
Fab swatches! Your pictures are trully amazing! Thank you! xoxo!
I’m a total Paint Pot virgin but after this post I soo want Rubenesque and Indianwood! They look like perfect bases for the summer.Think I’m gonna have to invest in Coral Crepe too. Great post!
[...] the better (although many would serve a much different purpose than “Painterly” because they are more pigmented and/or shimmery), but I bought this sight unseen so I can’t comment on any of the other shades. Also in its [...]
Such a great post. Pharaoh is absolutely amazing, I am currently on the search for one, stunning!
Try Specktra.net if you’re looking for Pharaoh. Lots of sellers on there are usually selling older paintpots like that one for decent prices.
Hi Resha I’m a newbie here on your site and in the world of makeup. I love your review of the paint pots as I’ve looked all over for reviews and found your review to be the BESTEST!!! I want to try them but I need your help with selecting the right one I’m a cross between Gabby Union and Lauren Hill’s color and I looovvveee neutrals, which paint pots would you suggest?? TIA
You’d look great in the Quite Natural paint pot if you’re going for a more subtle look, but no matter what your complexion is you can wear any and every paint pot under the sun. just because you’re dark skinned, doesn’t mean you cant. they work for every skin tone, i promise you. you just have to get used to having color on your eyes
this so helpful. thank you for the swatches!
Painterly and Soft Ochre look like great natural colours. Is it possible to wear them alone? I’m more of a darker skin tone too.
i wouldnt wear them alone just because they’re really kinda boring alone and would just look weird lol. rubenesque, indianwood, delft, and the frostier ones are nice when worn alone but the matte ones just wouldn’t really look right unless you blended it very well and followed it up with a dope cat-eye liner and tons of mascara maybe
Can you use this just as an eyeshadow? To give your lids, some color.
you absolutely can! i do with Indianwood and Delft all the time
I think I have a neutral skintone….it’s not pink or peach or yellow…in fact I have a tiny tiny hard to notice flush of pink to my cheeks…and I have fair skin…and tons of freckles and red/auburn hair…yes you guessed It..pale as a ghost practically…I think Porcelain or Soft Ivory in drugstore foundation shades… So which paint pot would be best for me ? Soft Ochre looks sooo nice..but you said painterly is perfect for making colors on the lid pop….also I think Rubenesque look awesome..I saw one on the site..and I know it’s LE but I hop I can possibly get my hands on it at least a sample…it’s called Nubile…I think it’s new..,anywhose…if you have You tube hit me up my username is : bluetigressemoon.
I can give you a link so you can better see my skin tone… http://www.myspace.com/tigerlily_luvs_all_peeps
If not I wll show you how to find me on FB for a better look….anway..awesome review! **Hugs** L8R =D
How long can u keep paint pots for before they go bad?
if the paint becomes really smelly (like a strong chemical scent) and/or separates itself from the rim of the container, u should toss it. if its still creamy, doesn’t smell too bad, etc…it’s fine. some of mine are slightly separated from the jar, but its a really thin 1px line. if its a huge gap, toss it.
This was incredibly helpful..thank you!
I just bought a used Delft from someone on Makeup Alley, it’s so pretty!
I’m very slooooly collecting these, i’ve been finding them at blog sales over at Makeup Alley.